Life As A Refugee Stranded In Indonesia | ASIAN BOSS

Komentar

  1. RonnieNolanRaharjo

    RonnieNolanRaharjo22 hari yang lalu

    To relieve them from the long limbo, the refugees should be moved to wealthy countries that are also signatories of the 1951 UN Refugee Convention. I propose that South Korea accept them. As a non-signatory to the UN Refugee Convention, Indonesia is not treaty-bound to host these people nor provide for them. It has no responsibility over these people whatsoever. Moreover, Indonesia is a developing country with a lot of its own poor. It would be asinine for the state to spend its meager resources on these illegal immigrants over its own poor who are living on far less comforts than what has been afforded to these illegal immigrants. There is no way to justify such spending. Hence, a wealthy signatory of the UN Refugee Convention like South Korea should accept them.

  2. kosa kata

    kosa kata20 hari yang lalu

    Do you know there are 26 million refugees? no country can handle that much refugees resettlement is not solution repatriation is the only way

  3. lennos Bepete

    lennos Bepete27 hari yang lalu

    I'm a foreigner in Jakarta now came for holiday and later to BALI,however what I realized is most indonesians are so babaric and pathetic how can you feel threatened by these people that shows most Indonesians are racist,in the streets of Jakarta the Indonesians are just loitering in the streets too much dirty,you should feel remorse for these refugees we are all equal as human beings, if I have anything to do in my power I would help.

  4. arif mark007

    arif mark00717 hari yang lalu

    Lol

  5. noidea

    noideaBulan Yang lalu

    The unique way to solve the mass migration is by helping the poor countries from where the refugees come from. Taking them is only a short-term solution.

  6. Audrey Theno

    Audrey ThenoBulan Yang lalu

    Oke lah kita sebagai warga Indonesia ngerti kondisi mereka, emang si agak kasian. Tpi ya jgn jelekin negara orang jg kali. Negara kita msih ada banyak daerah yang ga ada akses ke pendidikan yang layak atau pun air bersih aja. Banyak orang yang udh kerja susah payah buat kerja sampai ke ibu kota di Jakarta sekarang, terus kalau refugee ini tiba2 dateng dan dikasih kerja sm pemerintah kita, gmn orang2 itu yg udh kerja susah payah? Toh juga kalau dikasih kerja and nnti mereka suka Indonesia, mereka disini dong? Pemerintah kita sudah bantu sebisa mereka, sudah waktunya United Nations bertindak lebih cepat. Pemerintah kita bukanya ga mau bantu, tapi emg ga ad duit buat bantu. Kita aja skrg defisit dimn2 mau gmn bntu mreka toilet yg bnyk ato makan 3 kali sekali. Warga kita sendiri ada jg yg ga setiap hari makan, itu gmn tuh?

  7. Rabeb Aydi

    Rabeb Aydi2 bulan yang lalu

    This is heart breaking .... those refugees should come to tunisia ... we may be not that rich but at least here they will be treated as humans ... we are all one ummah and it really hurts seeing muslims humiliated in an other supposedly muslim country ...I always thought indenosians were nice people ..what a shame !!!

  8. 88 R I S I N G update

    88 R I S I N G updateBulan Yang lalu

    Yup sure everyone can say that easily.. tell me which country that doesn't have problem with refugee ..

  9. kosa kata

    kosa kataBulan Yang lalu

    They only want Australia, they will mocking tunisia as poor country LOL They want free housing, free education and free medical care. Thats why australian people also angry and close the door for refugees, that's why they stuck in indonesia.

  10. Alice in Payne

    Alice in Payne2 bulan yang lalu

    I can tell from the body language that the black guy from Sudan is a liar.

  11. kosa kata

    kosa kataBulan Yang lalu

    they economic migrant

  12. Little Blue

    Little Blue2 bulan yang lalu

    This dude has more than the homeless people there and he still complains wtf At least the homeless are grateful!

  13. Ken Gahayr

    Ken Gahayr2 bulan yang lalu

    Refugee people did not flee their country luck of money some of them were rich they run their own country because of danger and threatening in their life, so the question is if they had money why are they looking for shelter and food, this is because most of them run out their money and for those who had still the money are worrying about the future and how many more years they will spent here (Indonesia) again. In here they are transit and one day they will reach their final destination like Australia, Canada, America and New Zealand. As far as I know most Indonesians are very respectful people but refugee are strange to them and they don't have any clue. For those who know what is it meant to be refugee may never commented here negative thing.

  14. kosa kata

    kosa kata20 hari yang lalu

    ​@Ken Gahayr If you not believe me you can search Sajad Jacob family (commited suicide by burning himself), his brother "tahanan PBB" and sister "tahanan PBB 2" i think most refugees already know them, they already in indonesia since 2000, i know them from tv show and news, you can contact them directly for confirmation. Sorry i don't want hurt your feeling, but you better face reality and get another solution rather than wait for decade become oldman or might be die here because never be resettled

  15. Ken Gahayr

    Ken Gahayr20 hari yang lalu

    @kosa kata don't tell your father how to behave' meaning you hear but don't know how it's like, you are just telling me 20 yrs and how Indonesia government did not allow to host refugee but I know more than this. Thank to Allah🙌 who saves from you to be refugee.

  16. kosa kata

    kosa kata20 hari yang lalu

    @Ken Gahayr did you know there are refugees that already in indonesia for 20 yrs? did you know UNHCR ask refugees in indonesia to wait for additional 10 yrs or more? Faster? I think you that hear news and believe, not me

  17. Ken Gahayr

    Ken Gahayr20 hari yang lalu

    @kosa kata you don't nothing about asylum and refugee as well, I didn't miss geography class like some of you did I know how far Indonesia is accourding to the location , but there is many criteria that refugee choose here, this is because here is Muslim country, save and the process is faster than any other hostage refugee countries. you just hear news and believe, don't! Food and shelter are not important even though it's basic needs but moving here

  18. kosa kata

    kosa kata20 hari yang lalu

    @Ken Gahayr why not learn use map, what nearest country for seeking asylum? That statement from australian netizen not me, thats why they put slogan "No way make australia home" You can check the news, angry australian gov will cut more refugees funds, put refugees on port moresby prison and start deporting resettled asylum seeker by force.

  19. Wahyu Hidayat

    Wahyu Hidayat2 bulan yang lalu

    kita doakan yang terbaik buat mereka. kita kan gak tau apa yang mereka rasain dan alamin selama hidupnya. smoga cepat diterima ke negara ketiga.

  20. Veto Carleone

    Veto Carleone2 bulan yang lalu

    Thank you Indonesia for letting them transit. Love frm India

  21. Indonesian Tummy

    Indonesian Tummy2 bulan yang lalu

    This is make me sick as an Indonesian. We cant even provide shelter for our own people, and these refugees that already have shelter still ungrateful? GO BACK TO YOUR OWN COUNTRY! You guys only sit and sleep asking good food and facility? Shoot my brain. I work my ass off all day and still barely achieve that.

  22. kosa kata

    kosa kataBulan Yang lalu

    Same reason why australian also angry and close the door for refugees 😁😁 They just want free housing, education and medical care, they just economic migrant

  23. wahid Ubaidillah

    wahid Ubaidillah2 bulan yang lalu

    Itu yg pke kaos item sm topi item ga ngerti isu tp d wawancarai 😁😁😁

  24. Bagus Giri

    Bagus Giri2 bulan yang lalu

    "Do you accept refugees ?" "No, but they can live here" 😐

  25. mockizart

    mockizart2 bulan yang lalu

    I am a jakartan, an indonesia are welcoming them. I never hear any crimes that refugees commit here. so as long as they behave, it's just right thing to do to let them stay here.

  26. Tesya Phandiawan

    Tesya Phandiawan2 bulan yang lalu

    BAHAS TENTANG ISU RASISME DI PAPUA PLEASE

  27. K IE

    K IE2 bulan yang lalu

    Isn't it so incredible that everyone hates on the west for not wanting refugees yet when third world countries say it it's totally fine. It's disgusting. The west DOES NOT want refugees nor immigrants. Stay in your countries and improve your countries. We went through the same process of improvement over many years, suffering the same as you.

  28. kosa kata

    kosa kata20 hari yang lalu

    because west acting rich by promising provide lot free facility for refugees, meanwhile their homeless no one care XD

  29. Zeli Ang

    Zeli Ang2 bulan yang lalu

    Their are more than 21 million refugees in India

  30. Zeli Ang

    Zeli Ang2 bulan yang lalu

    @Mattew val Sorry i mean india

  31. Mattew val

    Mattew val2 bulan yang lalu

    Nope there are just 14 thousand.

  32. V. zoster

    V. zoster2 bulan yang lalu

    WOW the comments are disgusting and depressing

  33. Sturmmänner

    Sturmmänner2 bulan yang lalu

    Congrats you just described the current Paris condition

  34. Sio Ux

    Sio Ux2 bulan yang lalu

    Soal fisika quantum: Negara saya sedang konflik, saya melarikan diri dr negara saya. Pilihan yg sebaiknya saya ambil adalah: A. Ke Amerika, diperbatasan dicegat, lalu dikurung, dipisahkan anak sm ortu. B. Ke Eropa, sampai di perairan Italy berminggu2 terapung2 dilarang bersandar. C. Ke Australia, mampir ke Indonesia, ditampung, dikasih kebutuhan primer, betah, trus minta ini ono, di wawancara asian boss, viral, tambah betah dst... Yuk... Depeleh.. Depeleeeeh....

  35. Muhammad Baharuddin Al Fahmi

    Muhammad Baharuddin Al Fahmi2 bulan yang lalu

    Stop sharing video!

  36. Propa ganda

    Propa ganda2 bulan yang lalu

    ASIAN BOSS = Korean propaganda machine

  37. Doraemonfreak91

    Doraemonfreak912 bulan yang lalu

    I pity them but I don't support Indonesia to accept them. I truly feel sorry, but Indonesia is in no condition to support them. Indonesia is still a developing country struggling to find solution to its gazillion problems. If there're locals who still live below the standard, how can the governments provide aids for these refugees?

  38. Michael Alexander

    Michael Alexander2 bulan yang lalu

    pulangkan saja lha klo negaranya sdh tdk konflik lagi .. disini sumpek, kebanyakan orang ..

  39. Resita TP

    Resita TP2 bulan yang lalu

    They are always fed dude, they also get health checks from the department regularly. The government is also building a relief post. But they always ask for more facilities, then they also ask for a job even though from the beginning the requirements are indeed not allowed to work there. they say they don't have money, they say they don't look like humans but they play gadgets?! honestly I'm sad and sorry to see them :"

  40. Reja Dalimunthe

    Reja Dalimunthe2 bulan yang lalu

    I am Indonesian, I think Asian Boss chose people or interviewee that are not knowledgeable about the problems from the root. I dont know why and the reporter speaks like reading...ehmmm. This report is not sharp. I hope Asian Boss could hire me instead.

  41. Dinil Dinesh P

    Dinil Dinesh P2 bulan yang lalu

    1.7 M subscribers and only 45k views. Yeah I get it it's not related to Kpop or Japan but cmon. This shows that how much ignorant people are. I mean majority of them. This is sad.

  42. EleeaMi

    EleeaMi2 bulan yang lalu

    The Indonesian government must be firm, each country must return, it will damage the view of Jakarta

  43. Agus sugiharto

    Agus sugiharto2 bulan yang lalu

    Just put your self in their shoes. Dont be so selfish!

  44. Henny Susanto

    Henny Susanto2 bulan yang lalu

    How funny Indonesian are 😂 They keep saying "Save Palestine!", "Help our moeslem brother!" "Together we're moeslem!" But when there are "The REAL MOESLEM Brothers who need A REAL HELP", Indonesian ignore them, hate them, refuse them, scared of them.

  45. Aji Kurnia

    Aji Kurnia2 bulan yang lalu

    As another race? Yes. But if you're chinese, no matter if you're legal or illegal, the so called 'country-loving' Indonesian will threat you like a king or even a god.

  46. mejadije

    mejadije2 bulan yang lalu

    terancam enak keleus, nasi anget. uuuh.

  47. Windy Prisilia Aulele

    Windy Prisilia Aulele2 bulan yang lalu

    This is soo sad , I can't believe they're living like that, have no jobs and there are children there as well. Forget all about the paper and stuff , after all we all human beings in this small world. I respect that my country has tried to help them although not much, but I really hope whoever responsible for the paper /application or whatever can work this out faster. These ppl really need help. We're all human beings: just like us they also need better lives.

  48. cia o

    cia o2 bulan yang lalu

    I crushed at @1:37

  49. FRANSISCA NADYA

    FRANSISCA NADYA2 bulan yang lalu

    I live in Daan Mogot Baru, the residential complex refusing to accept them. Personally at first I feel pity for them, because they must move from their beloved country to other places. But when I know about their condition, such as: 1. Some of them get to come to Indonesia via illegal route. I know about this myself because my friend colleague is the person handing back door for smuggle them. And they pay lots of money 2. They get pocket money for living in Indonesia. Even though their business still running back in their country and even some try to expand thier business to Indonesia and buy property/land here. Btw my mom met a person which own a property near my home, because he’s trying to buy and fill his new property. He even tell my mom, he owns the property so he can run and have meeting for his business and make it into his office here in Indonesia. 3. I can’t say we marginalized them, because even my own church community and some other try to help them, by sending some food or other. But once (and most of the time) they don’t act greatful and don’t like it and just dump it to the trash bin. I also would say we don’t differenciate them, even they can go to collage and my neighbour chat with a father with graduated child in Indonesia. 4. They don’t act greatful and seems to taking advantage of our kindness. Just like asking some store owner to charge their phone and some other condition. 5. If you say they are isolated. I don’t think so. Because they have communication devices and the have their own free will and freedom to walk around and buy stuffs. And the reality why we, the resident of Daan Mogot Baru residential complex refusing them is because they really located and living in the place not purpose fully for living. The place only have limited bathroom, if I’m not mistaken around 3/4. Right next to the location the refugees living is a school, so it’s not the best and ideal place for living. That’s why we oppose them P. S.: just this afternoon the refugees in my area are rioting between each other and I heard even some police having great injury such as losing their hand/arm (I haven’t got more info)

  50. FRANSISCA NADYA

    FRANSISCA NADYA2 bulan yang lalu

    Btw just now there’s riot between refugees in my area. I hope you can relate with my and my community opinion of why we oppose n our insecurity

  51. Latifa Suri Wardani

    Latifa Suri Wardani2 bulan yang lalu

    anyone know where i can donate something for them?

  52. Jusy Like it

    Jusy Like it2 bulan yang lalu

    Bring them back to they own country,I refuse immigrants

  53. nathan nael

    nathan nael2 bulan yang lalu

    Please make a video about racism in indonesia , especially on recent muslim religious teacher that insulted christianity by mocking jesus on the cross.. also on papua people that are also being insulted and treated unfairly !!

  54. Night Vendor ID

    Night Vendor ID2 bulan yang lalu

    As far as i know, it should be UNHCR problem and not Indonesia problem, yet the refugees still complain to our government, not to mention lot of them has shitty atitude toward our country and keep comparing it to western country or developed country, and saying Indonesia is shitty country and everything, our country might not be perfect but at least we live in peace and safe, so maybe they are the one who arent grateful enough with their current condition.

  55. Rio Alfarez

    Rio Alfarez2 bulan yang lalu

    Looking at these people comments, gosh they are so dumb. They have serious problem in their own country and they are not even allowed to work that’s why they’re called refugee. Geez, do some research before you talk and what if you guys in their position?

  56. sapphirexwind

    sapphirexwind2 bulan yang lalu

    A lot of the refugees - if not most - are Muslim. A lot of Indonesians are Muslim too. Us that why there are so many admitted by the government? Why don't the Muslims of Indonesia stand up for their kindred? Are they all that different? I'm not Christian but I know that Christians would for others like them.

  57. Anarki Aksara

    Anarki Aksara2 bulan yang lalu

    Whaaat? No hijabi girl and other religion topic for Indonesian's series? What happened, Asian Boss? I'm very disappointed *sarcasm mode on

  58. justkumala

    justkumala2 bulan yang lalu

    So much negative comments , just don't talk if you don't know anything, for God sake

  59. Eko Sopiyantooo

    Eko Sopiyantooo2 bulan yang lalu

    Kasihan ya allah, kita harus banyak2 membantu mereka kita hidup harus bisa berguna untuk orang lain , ini kesempatan kita bersama bangsa indonesia membantu yang membutuhkan.

  60. aryo seto

    aryo seto2 bulan yang lalu

    Damn u africa, u ruins everything

  61. Dawud Abdul

    Dawud Abdul2 bulan yang lalu

    Finally real issue and not hijab-involving content. Nice Asian Boss, you're getting better.

  62. putra mahkota

    putra mahkota2 bulan yang lalu

    My question is how they reach in Indonesia anyone can explain how to get visa, how can they very easy travelling to Indonesia

  63. M.S. Oik

    M.S. Oik2 bulan yang lalu

    I think the goverment should think about many aspect before give place from refugees cause Indonesia isn't wealth country and the other Indonesians.... I can say anything

  64. Oro Cosplayer

    Oro Cosplayer2 bulan yang lalu

    wow.. 3 random person interviewed said that they are scared.. But none of them have close encounter, talking directly to those refugees.. I feel uncomfortable that those people said such things. What if they're in those refugees shoes? :) I pity these refugees..

  65. isi29 cup

    isi29 cup2 bulan yang lalu

    JUST LET THEM DIE ALREADY

  66. Zefanya Pardede

    Zefanya Pardede2 bulan yang lalu

    What's even more painful is that they live just 2.5 miles away from where I live. I see their camps near the pedestrian and children sitting under trees that aren't big enough to shade them all. It aches me that all I can do is offer them food and water.

  67. Oldysnglrs

    Oldysnglrs2 bulan yang lalu

    welp, many indonesian are racist... big ooft but too bad the imigrants in my city ( jakarta ofc ), they'll doin whatever they wan't without knowing our rules °^°)/ actually we feel bad for y'all imigrants here, but.. for all the conception, please be prepared bout knowin rules here. gbu y'all

  68. Hyuda

    Hyuda2 bulan yang lalu

    there still some land on east indonesia,take it (king of no life talk here)

  69. Safinah Mohamad

    Safinah Mohamad2 bulan yang lalu

    Not pity at all.

  70. Gabrielle Meloni

    Gabrielle Meloni2 bulan yang lalu

    Dear Asian Boss, Please get BETTER journalist.

  71. cag cag

    cag cag2 bulan yang lalu

    I'm a refugee in Jakarta. I have indonesian girlfriend. She has very nice body

  72. Sturmmänner

    Sturmmänner2 bulan yang lalu

    Disgusting

  73. arif mark007

    arif mark0072 bulan yang lalu

    @cag cag lol why you get access to work??

  74. cag cag

    cag cag2 bulan yang lalu

    @arif mark007 I work as translator. I need Internet for work. I'm from sudan

  75. arif mark007

    arif mark0072 bulan yang lalu

    Dont lying... Why you get internet acces?

  76. Christian Arriandi

    Christian Arriandi2 bulan yang lalu

    Kenapa pemerintah tidak pakai strategi waktu membantu pengungsi vietnam dulu? Kumpulkan mereka di tempat yang minim penduduk ( bukan di Jakarta atau pulau Jawa pastinya ) suruh mereka buat komunitas disitu seperti pulau Galang... Menurut saya itu lebih layak mengingat status mereka pengungsi bukan pelancong jadi gesekan dengan warga lokal bisa dikurangi. Just my random thought as Indonesian..

  77. Inay

    Inay2 bulan yang lalu

    Christian Arriandi kalo ga salah baca sih, refugee yg ini udah pernah ditawari hidup di daerah kalimantan dan di daerah timur sana, diberi tanah buat digarap dan uang untuk membantu sampe tanah menghasilkan. tapi mereka tolak dan tetap ingin stay disitu sampe permit mereka ke AUS atau negara yg mereka tuju awalnya granting the permit. jadi mungkin banyak warga sekitar atau indonesian yg sedikit risih juga. apalagi denger” ada kabar harrasment ke cewek local.

  78. Hadiyah Asma

    Hadiyah Asma2 bulan yang lalu

    I don’t think Indonesia is in a condition where we could help others. And I don’t want to be mean but if these people want to go to countries like Australia and America, what’s with their english? They won’t survive there either. Rather than wasting time waiting, could anyone help them improve themselves? Is that possible?

  79. Lailatul Qurrotaayunin

    Lailatul Qurrotaayunin2 bulan yang lalu

    I am sorry but can asian boss interview local people not from "warung" area, but also from university or worker place. So we can more diverse point of view

  80. Tha-

    Tha-2 bulan yang lalu

    to be completely honest, Indonesia is still a developing country and comparing us to australia is kinda harsh, since australia is far more developed than indonesia and has a huge different gdp compared to indonesia. some of us is struggling to even getting basic needs like water and food, and expecting us to accept and giving them basic needs for free is kinda unfair for some of us.

  81. Rizqy Alamsyah Wardhana

    Rizqy Alamsyah Wardhana2 bulan yang lalu

    I felt ashamed by my own country