How Do White Walkers Shatter Swords?

Komentar

  1. Because Science

    Because Science6 bulan yang lalu

    Thanks for watching super nerds! HUGE thanks to my good friend Allen Pan for his help on this -- definitely go subscribe to his channel if you want more stuff like this. And I hear you: do more of these kinds of videos! I'll try my best. Sometimes it's hard to get time/money/talent to come together, but I'll get some more going for you -- kH

  2. joey dahl

    joey dahl6 bulan yang lalu

    @Ran Wolf Yeah, that's what i want to know. I don't know effective, practically speaking, a lightsaber would be against wights since we have seen them able to move even with parts of the head missing. so you would have to carve them into little pieces. As for the walkers themselves they have shrugged off fire before. That said from what Because Science has talked about before a lightsaber is really, really hot.

  3. Derrick O'Neal

    Derrick O'Neal6 bulan yang lalu

    A theory I propose is that instead of simply freezing the metal maybe there's a form of physical and chemical change and the swords are being turned to water/ solid ice. That completely changes how the sword works. If we look at the show, the swords are shattering into ice...not frozen bits of metal.

  4. Marcello Gonzalez

    Marcello Gonzalez6 bulan yang lalu

    A bit off-topic, but I have read that photons can be emitted when an electron that has been excited (gained energy and moved into a higher electron shell) looses that energy and drops into its previous shell. If this is true, @Because Science, could you do such a thing to the electrons in a human to where the body will emit light similar to a lightbulb? If you could, then what would happen to the body?

  5. Nw2343

    Nw23436 bulan yang lalu

    Mr Pink Iron is also pretty ductile so pure iron wouldnt shatter no matter what the walkers tried . If it was a piece of steel just heattreared and not tempered it would shatter .The thing is non tempered heattreated steep shatters even without freezing it because it too brittle. But yes copper and bronze would be very good for cold resistance and if titanium exist it would work too because it is muvh better in dealing with temperature changes compared to steel and iron.

  6. Adom cw

    Adom cw5 hari yang lalu

    The idea of the resonance frequency idea for the shattering of the swords make very plausible sense given the way that the swords shatter. Though I have an additional theory to pair with this. When forging a sword, one of the most important processes is the heat treatment process. In a very high quality blade, we harden and temper the blade to make a very hard but resilient blade. However if it is not down right we leave stress points in the blade and make a brittle or malleable blade. Thus I think got smiths just don’t do a very good job at the heat treat or worse just harden their blades thus making them very brittle. Thus when hit by the white walkers, their strength and the low temperature just shatters the blade really easily.

  7. cody collins

    cody collinsBulan Yang lalu

    Where I live in Canada when it gets below -40 we shut down everything we can and dont work because you end up wreck more things than you actually get down

  8. vizthex

    vizthex2 bulan yang lalu

    wait isn't Liquid Helium colder?

  9. Isaac Clodfelter

    Isaac Clodfelter3 bulan yang lalu

    Allen's test was kinda flawed if I am thinking about it right. If the chilling of the blade happens when it hits the whitewalker' s sword then the sword would be going through thermal shock the same time as getting in a sword fight. Maybe thermal shock wouldn't matter in real life science with metals but if we are saying that the cold sword is like a magic heat sink then that with the force of the swing may lead to a shattered sword.

  10. Black Slayer

    Black Slayer3 bulan yang lalu

    i think there just using something cheap like gallium or aluminum ''its hollywood". but to say an actual mievil sword from that era, they were made poorly and unrefined

  11. Oleksiy Alkhazov

    Oleksiy Alkhazov3 bulan yang lalu

    Such a musical sound in the slowmo part when the cold sword is being hit against that metal rail or whatever it is

  12. Augustus Wayne

    Augustus Wayne4 bulan yang lalu

    Maybe the sword wasn't so crappy after all !?!?

  13. Kody Ross

    Kody Ross4 bulan yang lalu

    This has made me think that Kyle might be a faceless man. And if you never hear from me again then you know wether or not I was right.

  14. Fred Prekel

    Fred Prekel4 bulan yang lalu

    dragon glass is Obsidian they mentioned that in the series

  15. Sammumoo~

    Sammumoo~5 bulan yang lalu

    I want your hair

  16. Eli Nelson

    Eli Nelson5 bulan yang lalu

    That's not an I beam

  17. GrandAdmiral Zod

    GrandAdmiral Zod6 bulan yang lalu

    So they got a 120 pound nerd to swing a sword at the speed that a small child swings a TBall bat. Yup that's exactly the same as two battle hardened warriors hitting the sharp edges of the blades. Exactly the same I say!

  18. The World Of Panda

    The World Of Panda6 bulan yang lalu

    but the sword wasnt struck at optimal temperatures, that was suck a long time before the first strike and impacts like that just heated it up further, might not be possible still but wasnt done optimally

  19. Atharv Sharma

    Atharv Sharma6 bulan yang lalu

    wait but ice wont get more brittle if I overfreeze it ,will it ?

  20. Dante The Dark Demon

    Dante The Dark Demon6 bulan yang lalu

    In the back to the future trilogy. Why don't the tires melt from time travel? They leave flaming tracks but don't melt from the heat? Why is that?

  21. Aky Alex

    Aky Alex6 bulan yang lalu

    that retard lost way too much time

  22. l l

    l l6 bulan yang lalu

    The sword could have been poorly made with high inclusions of slag and carbon. It could have had too much carbon in it (1.6% or more by weight), making it white iron instead of steel. Then it would be brittle at room temperature.

  23. Roger Skagerström

    Roger Skagerström6 bulan yang lalu

    Because Sience - taking good ol' Mythbusters place in the void!

  24. Fistfullofboomstick

    Fistfullofboomstick6 bulan yang lalu

    oh hey! i know why the sword shattered so easily at hardhome! ya see, they have a really bad habit of forging swords out of cast iron. it has so many bubbles and pits that it shatters on contact with pretty much anything. so a white walkers weapon, or WWW, wouldn't have to try very hard to do even worse. so really, maybe valerian steel is what we here call "regular steel" while westeros mistakenly refers to cast iron as steel.

  25. Russtastic Voyage

    Russtastic Voyage6 bulan yang lalu

    So if they can shatter swords with a touch, then how the hell does arya have a throat?

  26. Man Of Steel

    Man Of Steel6 bulan yang lalu

    This was a lot of talk about "tempeture"..

  27. Foster Paulsen

    Foster Paulsen6 bulan yang lalu

    Hey Kyle! Newer watcher of the show. I was wondering several things while you were talking about the composition of the sword. Is it possible that what they call “steel” and “valerian steel” (never watched GoT) are just misnomers? Would something more akin to Iron, which is much weaker structurally than steel, could be what they call “steel” and ACTUAL steel is their so called “valerian steel”? Also, one thought has been lingering from Alan’s experiment: That sword may have been crappy, but it was made using modern methods with modern materials. It could be that the sword he used was just better than the older style forging. Maybe there’s a scene of someone forging their blades?

  28. Foster Paulsen

    Foster Paulsen6 bulan yang lalu

    Edit: is it possible the Valyrian steel is just Damascus, which is harder than regular steel once hardened?

  29. Foster Paulsen

    Foster Paulsen6 bulan yang lalu

    Hey Kyle! Newer watcher of the show. I was wondering several things while you were talking about the composition of the sword. Is it possible that what they call “steel” and “valerian steel” (never watched GoT) are just misnomers? Would something more akin to Iron, which is much weaker structurally than steel, could be what they call “steel” and ACTUAL steel is their so called “valerian steel”? Also, one thought has been lingering from Alan’s experiment: That sword may have been crappy, but it was made using modern methods with modern materials. It could be that the sword he used was just better than the older style forging. Maybe there’s a scene of someone forging their blades?

  30. Caomhan McGowan

    Caomhan McGowan6 bulan yang lalu

    Not 100% on this but like 90%. The test done for this doesn't seem to be credible, the liquid nitrogen and stuff I agree with (although that didn't look like an I beam), but he said that the sword was cheap and made from carbon steel (VAGUE). Between that and how it looks leads me to believe that it's S275(cheap and most common steel, in Europe anyway). Lower carbon content in steels cause it to be more ductile so... NO ONE IN THEIR RIGHT MIND WOULD MAKE A SWORD (to fight with) FROM THIS MATERIAL. Should have used a sword made from something like W2 (common sword and knife material with high carbon content) the higher the carbon content, the higher the hardness and the more brittle the sword will be. This has been an alcohol fuelled rant from a mechanical engineering student.

  31. Jamez landers

    Jamez landers6 bulan yang lalu

    I would have gone with "Castle Vanta Black"

  32. nobetternickname

    nobetternickname6 bulan yang lalu

    this was the perfect episode to study the strange way kyle chooses to pronounce 'temperature'. 😁 or is it just me? surely most people say it like: temp-rature instead of temper-ture. 🤔

  33. John Wertz

    John Wertz6 bulan yang lalu

    Just as easily could have made the sword of fire and ice pun. But likely more GoT nerds here than MTG nerds

  34. El_Gymnast

    El_Gymnast6 bulan yang lalu

    Your puns give me life

  35. Miguel Angel Rangel

    Miguel Angel Rangel6 bulan yang lalu

    The steel used for modern swords is "spring metal", flexible and hardy (they can witstand a lot of punishment); back in times like the medieval age (the time that GoT takes inspiration from) steel wasn't of that much quality, it's somethin people tend to forget, the steel we use ain't the steel our ancestors used, their steel was more frail, less pure and with other problematics, and that's why folding and differential tempering existed (that's why katanas have that that weird wavy thing).

  36. Misterlikeseverythin

    Misterlikeseverythin6 bulan yang lalu

    Stainless steel alloys do not become that brittle at low T. Could it be that Amazon sword was made from an alloy with chromium?

  37. Chase Murphy

    Chase Murphy6 bulan yang lalu

    I don't think it would've shattered anyways, but you should've pulled it out after soaking for a few minutes and then smacked it on the beam immediately, not a minute later after it had time to warm back up a significant amount

  38. Magnus Winther

    Magnus Winther6 bulan yang lalu

    Or maybe they use some kind of sonic vibration, or a combination of it and freezing. Would this be possible?

  39. André / Pyroghoul

    André / Pyroghoul6 bulan yang lalu

    4:11 ...like nipples. The North hates nipples.

  40. Jarrett Linden

    Jarrett Linden6 bulan yang lalu

    Isn’t modern steel (even crappy modern steel) still way better than steel they would have had in the past ? Maybe If the steel was made of iron it would shatter easier. In my experience this is true

  41. TiagoTiago

    TiagoTiago6 bulan yang lalu

    Maybe they shatter due to water expanding into ice inside cracks on the sword?

  42. Colton  Scalf

    Colton Scalf6 bulan yang lalu

    You have to remember also that white walkers are stronger than humans.

  43. Perfectdarkqc

    Perfectdarkqc6 bulan yang lalu

    And of course i got a GoT ad.

  44. Jeff NME

    Jeff NME6 bulan yang lalu

    The reason why your "el cheapo from the internet" didn't shatter is probably because it's made of mild steel, a low-carbon steel which is quite ductile even when cryogenically cooled. A proper carbon tool steel which can take a good edge would be harder and more brittle when super-cooled.

  45. Evan Schubert

    Evan Schubert6 bulan yang lalu

    its really weird watching Allen Pan with the Because Science background music

  46. The Devil's Hopyard

    The Devil's Hopyard6 bulan yang lalu

    It’s not temperature but the vibrational frequency imparted from the white walker weapon to his opponent. Non valyrian steel swords have resonant frequencies which make them vulnerable to WW weapons. Think earthquakes vs non earthquake proof buildings.

  47. Adam

    Adam6 bulan yang lalu

    Maybe those swords that shatters were just iron?(much more brittle than steel)

  48. Lorelei Marivaine

    Lorelei Marivaine6 bulan yang lalu

    The phrase “Of Ice and Fire” just reminds me of Sonic Boom and no one needs to be reminded of Sonic Boom.

  49. Adom Smith

    Adom Smith6 bulan yang lalu

    I dont wat h Game of thrones but I have a question. If the white Walker was swinging its sword wouldnt we want to swing the I beam too?

  50. cody pannell

    cody pannell6 bulan yang lalu

    Noooooooooooooooo!!!!!!! I thought we got rid of that guy from the MK series..... Why bring is half baked experiments to a good show?......

  51. DeborahFishburn

    DeborahFishburn6 bulan yang lalu

    Please note the number of syllables in tempERatures

  52. Billy Murray

    Billy Murray6 bulan yang lalu

    Well he was using a wildling sword so I would assume it would be pretty low carbon content maybe around .1%. I know some swords from the 11th-12th centurys have around that amount of carbon. Try redoing the test with a more correct steel. I would be curious to see if the outcome changes.

  53. Apple

    Apple6 bulan yang lalu

    Wow I knew Thor was smart but i didn’t know he was that smart

  54. Photo Spectrum

    Photo Spectrum6 bulan yang lalu

    This was a cool episode!

  55. Ronny Shama

    Ronny Shama6 bulan yang lalu

    Frost zombie sounds better than ice zombie

  56. Chinedu Opara

    Chinedu Opara6 bulan yang lalu

    Also, the white walker's "weapon" (just a metal bar) wasn't 100% immovable.

  57. Chinedu Opara

    Chinedu Opara6 bulan yang lalu

    I'm trademarking "Kyle's Luscious Locks" , folks. Don't steal it.

  58. Chinedu Opara

    Chinedu Opara6 bulan yang lalu

    Why does the "White Walker" look like a *BDSM* mannequin?

  59. Zach Gunderson

    Zach Gunderson6 bulan yang lalu

    Valyrian steel is probably made with dragonglass. Bet.

  60. Kelvin Cermeno

    Kelvin Cermeno6 bulan yang lalu

    This reminds me of how ceramic bits from a spark plug shatters glass in an instant, could be the same principle in the show but obviously with differed materials lol

  61. Getason Geta

    Getason Geta6 bulan yang lalu

    They should have tried it with the hanwei tinker longsword..

  62. laser8389

    laser83896 bulan yang lalu

    If this was a cheap sword, it's likely what Shad from Shadiversity would call a sword-like object (SLO). They generally lack the distal tapering (decreasing the flat-to-flat distance when going from hilt to point) found on real swords. This bulkier geometry may reinforce the material.

  63. fraser leslie

    fraser leslie6 bulan yang lalu

    Materials exam revison ✔

  64. HGGundamreviews

    HGGundamreviews6 bulan yang lalu

    As just a bit of GoT lore info, the implications from the books are that Valyrian-steel was made using Dragon Fired Forges, using an alloy made up of Steel and Dragon Glass/Obsidian. Not something I think would work IRL. But it's book magic and well, that adds in a unknowable variable into the mix.

  65. Tim Nim Andersen

    Tim Nim Andersen6 bulan yang lalu

    A sword might not shatter even when that cold(even though the sword seemed to have heathed since he could hold it with one hand), however since it's "magic" and the sword is being freezed instantly, wouldn't the sudden change combined with a sudden hard blow make a difference?